Experiments / Research

Experiments / Research

Experiments / Research

Welcome to the Copy-Paste World: Where AI Turning every Brand into a same Template.

November 17, 2025

wortham logo
wortham logo
wortham logo

That's what scrolling through Instagram feels like in 2025. Every brand, every influencer, every "disruptive startup" looks like they're wearing the same outfit to the same party, pretending they came up with the look independently.

Welcome to the Copy-Paste age, where artificial intelligence promised to democratize creativity and instead created the world's largest Xerox machine for ideas, designs, and brand identities.

The Great Marketing Homogenization: A Love Story

Let us paint you a picture. There are now approximately 4,700 wellness brands that all:

  • Use the same millennial pink and sage green color palette

  • Have names like "Ritual," "Ceremony," "Bloom," or "Haven"

  • Feature the exact same photo of a woman in a cream-colored sweater holding a mug by a window

  • Write captions that start with "Gentle reminder:" or "Hot take:"

  • Sell $65 candles that smell like "mindfulness"

The hilarious part? They all think they're unique. They all hired different AI tools to help with branding. They all received the same advice. Because the AI tools all learned from the same successful brands, which learned from the same marketing gurus, who learned from the same data about what "converts."

"We've built an economy where everyone is fishing in the same pool with the same bait, wondering why the fish stopped biting."

The Content Cloning Crisis: When TikTok Became a Hall of Mirrors

Remember when TikTok was weird and unpredictable? When someone would do something genuinely bizarre and everyone would be like, "What did I just watch?"

Those days are dead. Murdered by optimization.

Now we have:

  • The Morning Routine Industrial Complex: 10,000 influencers all waking up at 5 AM, drinking lemon water, journaling, and going to the gym. almost Same angles. almost Same lighting. Same Lofi hip-hop background music. If morning routines were this powerful, we'd all be billionaires by now.

  • The "Unhinged" Marketing Trend: Every brand trying to be "relatable" and "unhinged" in the exact same calculated way. It's like watching 50 people at a party all trying to be "the funny one" using the same three jokes. Now even every SaaS company thinks saying "bestie no ❤️" is revolutionary.

  • The Entrepreneur Aesthetic: You've seen them. Always filming in their car. Always giving "harsh truths the algorithm doesn't want you to hear." Always pointing at text that appears above their head. I'm convinced there are only three actual people making these videos, and everyone else is just deepfaking their face onto the template.

"The algorithm doesn't reward creativity anymore. It rewards the ability to recognize what worked yesterday and reproduce it faster than your competitor."

The Reel Deal: When Every Video Became the Same Video

Here's a fun drinking game: Open Instagram Reels. Take a shot every time you see:

  • Someone lip-syncing to the same viral sound from three weeks ago

  • A "transition" video where someone changes outfits

  • "3 things I wish I knew before (insert literally anything)"

  • Text that says "Wait for it..." (Spoiler: it's never worth the wait)

  • A "day in the life" that looks suspiciously like every other day in every other life

Actually, don't play this game. You'll need a new liver.

The AI content recommendation algorithms have created a fascinating phenomenon: they've made it impossible to post something that doesn't look like something else. The machine learned what gets engagement, taught creators to replicate it, and now we're trapped in an infinite loop of content that feels like déjà vu had a baby with Groundhog Day.

The Idea Laundering Machine: How AI Made Plagiarism Scale

Here's where things get darkly hilarious. We now have:

AI tools that "help you create unique content" by:

  1. Scanning successful posts in your niche

  2. Identifying patterns in what performs well

  3. Generating "original" content based on those patterns

  4. Producing something that's technically not plagiarism but spiritually absolutely is

It's like if I told you, "I didn't copy your homework, I just used AI to analyze your answers and generate statistically similar responses." Technically different. Functionally identical.

The best part? Everyone's doing it. So you have:

  • Marketing Agency A using AI to analyze successful campaigns

  • Marketing Agency B using different AI to analyze the same campaigns

  • Both agencies producing nearly identical strategies

  • Both claiming they're "data-driven innovators"

  • Both billing $50,000 for what is essentially very expensive copy-paste

"We've automated creativity to death and called it innovation. It's like inventing a robot that perfectly replicates mediocrity at scale."

The Copyright Paradox: Stealing From Everyone and No One

Now here's where the legal world enters the chat, looking confused and slightly panicked.

The Current Copyright Nightmare:

AI tools are trained on millions of copyrighted works—designs, photos, articles, videos, music. They learn patterns from this content, then generate "new" work that's technically original but definitely inspired by (read: uncomfortably similar to) copyrighted material.

The legal question: Is this transformative use or just automated theft with extra steps?

Real-world examples that make lawyers cry:

  1. The Getty Images Watermark Incident: When AI image generators literally created images with scrambled Getty Images watermarks in them. The algorithm learned watermarks were part of "professional photos" and included them in the output. It's like if your kid drew a picture and accidentally included "©Adobe Stock" in the corner.

  2. The Music Industry Meltdown: AI tools creating songs "in the style of" famous artists. Legally murky. Ethically questionable. Creatively... just sad? Imagine AI Drake collabing with AI Taylor Swift on a song that AI Spotify's algorithm determined would get the most streams. Nobody asked for this dystopia.

  3. The Writing Scandal: Students using AI to write essays, employees using AI to write reports, authors using AI to write books. At what point is it assistance versus authorship? If I dictate to Siri, that's still my writing. If AI writes 90% and I edit 10%, is it still mine? Philosophy departments everywhere are having a field day. Even we are taking help of AI to write this blog.

Global Copyright Chaos:

  • Europe: Implementing strict AI regulations requiring transparency about training data. Very organized, very German in energy.

  • United States: Courts arguing about it while tech companies sprint ahead. Peak American energy.

  • China: Creating their own AI systems with their own rules. Not playing the same game.

  • Everyone else: Trying to figure out whether to copy Europe's homework or America's homework (the irony is not lost).

"We've created a technology that can steal from everyone simultaneously, and we're arguing about whether it's technically theft if the algorithm doesn't know it's stealing."

The Template Economy: Where Every Brand Has the Same Birthday

Let me tell you about a recent conference I attended. Seven different startups pitched. I swear to you:

  • Six used the same pitch deck template (shout out to that one Canva template doing heavy lifting)

  • Five had websites built on Webflow with identical layouts

  • All seven described themselves as "the Uber of (something)"

  • All seven had "AI-powered" in their description

  • Not one could explain what made them different without using the word "seamless"

This is what happens when AI democratizes access to "best practices." Everyone gets the same best practices. Which makes them no longer "best" or "practices"—just "standard" and "mandatory."

The Startup Bingo Card:

  • Gradient logo

  • "We're building a community"

  • "Disrupting" an industry

  • Using "insights" when you mean "guesses"

  • Stock photo of diverse people laughing at a laptop

  • Mission statement using "empower," "transform," and "revolutionize"

If you got bingo, congratulations! Your startup is indistinguishable from 10,000 others.

The Great Irony: AI Made Us All More Predictable

Here's the joke the universe is playing on us: We created artificial intelligence to help us be more creative, innovative, and successful. Instead, it made us all:

  • Say the same things

  • Make the same content

  • Follow the same trends

  • Chase the same metrics

  • Fear the same failures

It's like we invented a creativity machine and accidentally built a conformity engine.

"The algorithm promised to help us find our unique voice. Instead, it taught us all to sing the same song in perfect, soulless harmony."

Real-World Casualties of the Copy-Paste Era

Fashion brands: Remember when brands had distinct aesthetics? Now everyone's doing "coastal grandmother" or "dark academia" because the algorithm said so. Even luxury brands are making "quiet luxury" content identical to fast fashion brands making "quiet luxury" content.

Restaurants: Every new restaurant has exposed brick, Edison bulbs, and a menu describing food as "locally-sourced" and "thoughtfully prepared." Go to three different restaurants and you probably realize which was which. They all had the same reclaimed wood tables and the same font on their menus (it's always some variation of a handwritten script).

Personal Branding: LinkedIn has become a graveyard of people trying to be "authentic" in the exact same way. Everyone's sharing "vulnerable" posts that follow the same structure: "Last year, I relatable struggle. Today, I impressive (achievement). Here's what I learned: (obvious advice)Agree? ♻️ Repost to help your network." and the Fx@$#k motivational people are there , creating the same content in different ways just for the sake of Professionalism and leadership though.

Thousands of these. Daily. All claiming to be authentic while following the same formula for authenticity.

The Copyright Lawsuit Olympics: Coming Soon to a Court Near You

As of 2025, we're watching several fascinating legal battles:

The "Styles Cannot Be Copyrighted" Defense: Artists suing AI companies for training on their work. AI companies arguing they just learned "style" not specific content. Courts trying to figure out if there's a meaningful difference. Artists pointing out that "style" IS their work. Everyone confused.

The Voice Clone Wars: Celebrity voices being replicated by AI. Some celebrities licensed their voices, some didn't. Now there are AI podcasts featuring "conversations" between dead celebrities who never met. Legal? Ethical? Dystopian? Yes to all three?

The Derivative Work Dilemma: If AI generates an image based on millions of other images, is the output derivative? Is it transformative? How similar is too similar? These questions are being argued by lawyers billing $1,000/hour to discuss images of cats wearing sunglasses.

"We're in a weird timeline where you can't legally sing 'Happy Birthday' at a restaurant, but AI can create a song that sounds exactly like your favorite artist and sell it."

The Way Out: Being Weird on Purpose

Here's the good news: In the Copy-Paste Economy, being genuinely different is the ultimate competitive advantage.

Brands that are winning by being weird:

  • Liquid Death: Made water cool by pretending it's an energy drink for metalheads

  • Duolingo: Their TikTok strategy is just a guy in an owl costume being increasingly unhinged (and it actually IS unhinged, not corporate-unhinged)

  • Grimace: McDonald's accidentally created a meme character that dominated social media by... doing nothing? Being purple? Nobody knows and that's the point

These brands aren't asking AI what converts. They're asking humans what's funny, surprising, and memorable.

The Manifesto: How to Escape the Template

For Content Creators:

  • If AI suggests it, do the opposite

  • If it worked for someone else, it won't work for you

  • If you can describe your content as "(popular format) but about
    (your niche)," start over

  • Make something you'd want to watch, not something you think the algorithm wants

For Brands:

  • Fire your algorithm consultant (this is a joke) (but also...)

  • Hire weird people with weird ideas

  • Test things that don't make sense on paper

  • Remember: virality is random, but memorability is intentional

For Everyone:

  • Stop optimizing for engagement and start optimizing for "would I remember this tomorrow?"

  • Copyright laws might be confusing, but originality isn't: if you made it yourself, you're good

  • The best ideas come from humans being strange, not machines being efficient

"The future belongs not to those who can copy fastest, but to those who dare to be copied."

The Final Word: Choose Your Own Adventure

We're at a crossroads. Path A leads to an infinite beige hellscape where every brand, every creator, and every idea is optimized into indistinguishability. Path B leads to... well, we don't know yet. That's why it's interesting.

The Copy-Paste Economy will continue to thrive as long as we let algorithms tell us what works. But here's the secret they don't want you to know: the algorithm doesn't know what works next. It only knows what worked yesterday.

The brands, creators, and ideas that will matter five years from now aren't being recommended by AI tools today. They're being laughed at by focus groups, rejected by algorithms, and called "too weird" by consultants.

And that's exactly why they'll win.

"In a world where everyone sounds the same, having something to say becomes revolutionary."

P.S. If you're reading this and thinking "but my AI-generated content strategy is working," congratulations! It's working for everyone. That's precisely the problem. See you in the homogeneous hellscape, where we'll all be wearing the same gradient logo and calling it innovation.

P.P.S. If any AI tool tries to generate "content inspired by" this article, I want 47% of the revenue and an admission that irony is dead. Copyright laws might not protect style, but karma may be protects satire.

Comments

Comments

Continue Reading

The latest handpicked blog articles

Get started with Wortham.

Book a brief call - Zero obligation, just open conversation.

Get started with Wortham.

Book a brief call - Zero obligation, just open conversation.

Get started with Wortham.

Book a brief call - Zero obligation, just open conversation.